Courtyard tap · the corroded one by the bucket

Replace it yourself, or call?

Everything the job needs, what it costs either way, and where it can go wrong — so the decision is a tally, not a gut call. Front-yard tap stays as-is.

The job in one picture

One joint, two wrenches
inside the wall old elbow — do NOT let this twist wall plate nipple (1″ exposed) old faucet wrench 1: HOLD grips the nipple, doesn't turn wrench 2: TURN counterclockwise, steady pass/fail rule: wall plate or nipple starts rotating → STOP
The exposed inch of nipple is the whole reason this is doable. Hold it, and the wall never feels the torque.

Tools

Check what you already own · total updates

Parts

Home Depot, plumbing aisle

The job

~45 minutes if it cooperates · 90 if it fights
1

Water off at the main · 2 min

Then open the old bib and the splitter to drain the line.

2

Make room · 3 min

Drag the sand bucket sideways a few inches. Unscrew the splitter off the old faucet.

3

Oil and heat · 20 min, mostly waiting

Penetrating oil on the joint. Wait 15. Hair dryer on the brass hex for 2 minutes right before you pull.

4

Two wrenches · 5 min

Pipe wrench 1 clamped on the exposed nipple, holding. Wrench 2 on the faucet hex, counterclockwise, steady increasing force. It cracks, then spins.

5

The stop rule · watch

Wall plate or nipple rotating? Stop. Either unscrew the nipple fully and fit the spare, or that's your plumber cue. Never keep cranking a moving nipple.

6

Clean and tape · 5 min

Wire-brush the nipple threads. 3–4 wraps Teflon, clockwise so it tightens as the faucet screws on.

7

New faucet on · 5 min

Hand-tight, then wrench a half to one turn until snug with the spout pointing down. Back-hold the nipple again while you do it.

8

Rebuild the train · 5 min

Vacuum breaker → splitter → quick connects → hose and irrigation. Water on. Watch the wall joint for 5 minutes.

What can go wrong

Honest odds for a rusty galvanized nipple
EventOddsOutcome
Faucet comes off clean~65%Done in under an hour. $30–60 in parts.
Nipple unscrews from the elbow instead~25%Fine. Screw in the spare nipple, carry on. +10 min.
Nipple shears at the wall~10%Needs a nipple extractor (~$12) or a plumber. Water stays off until fixed. No wall damage.
Elbow inside the wall cracksrare with a back-holdPlumber, and possibly opening the wall. This is the one the back-hold prevents.
The back-hold is the whole risk story. Skip it and the rare outcome becomes a real one. Do it and the worst likely case is a sheared nipple — annoying, not expensive.

The plumber option

What it costs to not do this

Nationally, replacing a hose bib costs an average of $300, with most projects landing between $200 and $600, and a simple standard swap typically comes in around $150. San Francisco rates run above national — plan on a service-call minimum of roughly $150–250 plus the hour — so a realistic SF quote for this exact job is $250–450, more if the nipple shears and they open the wall.

What you get for it: they own the shear risk. If the nipple snaps, that's their problem to extract, not yours.

Decide

Tap yes/no · the verdict updates
You can get two wrenches on it once the bucket is moved
The exposed nipple inch is solid, not flaking rust
You know where the house main shutoff is and it works
Losing courtyard water for a day if it goes wrong is acceptable
You'd rather spend $60 and an hour than $350
Tick the boxesFive questions. The main shutoff one matters most.